George Rogers Howell wrote, "At first largely devoted to curiosities and freaks of nature, the Siamese Twins, Joyce Heth, Tom Thumb and other Barnum enterprises were exhibited here. Concerts, monologues, lectures and light entertainments of various sorts were frequently given, and more and more the place assumed a dramatic character. In 1848 it was considerably enlarged, and then became the leading, and at times the only place of amusement in the city . . . The last performance was given here April 28, 1855."The building continued on, housing offices and occasional public events. It was replaced in 1904 by a grander, but no less rounded, building that was home to the First Trust Company, and designed by Marcus T. Reynolds, who also designed its neighbor across the plaza, the D&H Railroad Headquarters (now SUNY Central Administration).
Other than the shape of that facade, the rest of Broadway in this view is gone except for a little stretch of buildings just past Pine Street.